Vedas are above thinking mind

 X writes/speaks finding of his/her research

This knowledge is transmitted using his/her words

These words are perceived by Y based on his/her own understanding 

This understanding is bound to approximation of X's understanding by providing methodologies used to arrive at conclusions 

Yet Y understand based on his/her own words or express so in his/her own words

Vedas are collection of Mantras

These mantras are recited at times given by Jyotish, written and preserved using Vyakaran, recited using sounds of Sikshya, methods are decided by Kalpa and the difficult phrases are decided using Nirukta. There is no place to rearrange words or use other methods or other sounds or other time. 

There is no alteration allowed, no experiments allowed, etc. That is there is no way to understand it using others' words or how they understand and following which we can understand. These mantras are to be found after recitation and be guiding mind after they starts to evolve into understanding of the reciter. 

Hence, Vedas are above mind. It can't be thought of or altered. No experiment is possible, no methodology can be prescribed other than recitation. 

these arguments are incomplete........